Tyler is a Catholic who's family is loving, but very sensitive when it comes to Catholicism. Josh is an atheist who's family is very strict, and they hate him for his sinful nature, promising his soul will be sent away to Purgatory. When Tyler meets him for the first time at Catholic Mass, he is determined to help him believe in the Lord. But it will not be easy.

Josh was born with a rare syndrome that gave him merman abilities, like breathing underwater and living in the ocean. Because of this, he cannot live like normal humans. After falling in love with a beautiful boy named Tyler, Josh wishes to become human. But he'll have to give up his soul.