Once upon a time, there was a girl named Star. She thought she loved a guy named Bryce. She was fond of the idea of them being together; he was her first love. However, she always felt her and Bryce was never going to be an official couple. He always kept her around in the background, ignoring her in public, especially when he was with Anaya. In all actuality, she later learned that he was just using her for pleasure; not really having any feelings for her at all. And if he did, he never showed it. She went all out for this boy who didn't feel the same way about her. Then she met Calvin. At first they was friends, never imagining it would be anymore than that. Star started to develop feelings for Calvin she couldn't describe. She kept them to herself; she didn't think Calvin felt the same way about her, or that her feelings for him was even real. He was a player; he never had the same girl around for too long. Her feelings grew stronger daily, yet her faith that her and Calvin would be together one day grew older and weaker. She didn't know how to feel because she really wanted a chance with Calvin, even though those feelings weren't being reciprocated back to her. Sure, in between his girlfriends, they talked, messed around, flirted, and hung out more, but it was just to have fun. Neither one thought it could turn into an official thing. Randomly, one night, he asked her to be his girl. She thought it was a joke. Or maybe it was a dream. Looking into his eyes and seeing her dream was actually coming true, she immediately said yes without hesitation. She thought she made the best decision of her life. But is that truly where her happily ever after tale finishes?

What if Elena had a twin sister Karin who acted similar to Katherine but is a vampire hunter? What happens when they meet the Salvatore brothers for the first time and fall in love without knowing about Katherine and vampires? What if Damon only wanted Karin because she's exactly like Katherin? Will they fall in love for real or just for fun? Her name is Karin Gilbert the other doppleganger.