"You did all this?" Pure Vanilla asked, voice quiet but filled with awe. "Surprise!" Shadow Milk did a little spin, then leaned in close with a mischievous grin. "I may have also commissioned a flock of butterflies, but they chickened out. Cowards-" The hero huffed a small laugh, but he held a soft expression. "It's... breathtaking. Thank you." Hughhhh cookie pornn 😫 ...with plot? Oh no. I didn't ask for plot! Why do I always give them plot and feelings!? NOOOO (Hell yeah I stole that title from the game!) Word Count: 7,201 Art by vnthers on X

"...We're lost, aren't we," Shadow Milk said under his breath. "I never said that." "You didn't have to." Oops. My fingers slipped and suddenly there was shadowvanilla smut in front of me... Now what are the odds of that? Word count: 6,417 Art by @molassessoup on X

Pure Vanilla regretted touching that orb. Admittedly, it was beautiful. A bright, cerulean blue orb. It looked like the ocean - no, like space. Both? It didn't matter; it was breathtaking. And oh, the way it was wrapped in shimmering gold, adorned with delicate little flowers. It was mesmerizing. Pure Vanilla couldn't help himself- He had to touch it. Pure Vanilla Cookie finds himself back in time time, in The Spire of Knowledge. The Fount of Knowledge takes interest in his pretty little time-anomaly. Aka 23k+ words of porn with lots and lots of plot. You're welcome! This was NOT beta read! NOT!!! There will probably be some mistakes- I'm only human 💔 Word Count: 23,516 Cover Art by lycheenfruit on tumblr

Shadow Milk Cookie is not soft. He isn't kind, and he doesn't tell the truth. Pure Vanilla Cookie would beg to differ. A sappy story following our favorite cookie duo, from redemption and patience, to love and understanding. And then of course, let's spice it up ;) Top Shadow Milk Cookie in this economy!? Wow, that's insane! Word Count: 10,420 Cover Art by @fruitsjellies on X

top: pure vanilla bottom: shadow milk I really like shadowvanilla... also this one is a little more tame than my last story (I think) it has a bit more plot and it's more gentle but it's still rough so js fair warning ALSO I headcanon shadow milk as transmasc so he'll have a vagina in this story so if you don't like that then click off okay thank youuu and this will contain soul play because I LOVE soul play

As Shadow milk goes through grief over his loss, Pure Vanilla tries to help him but has ulterior motives.

{TW⚠️}Contains: Pure Vanilla Angst (SLIGHT SMUT) Pure Vanilla Angst Concerned Shadow Milk cookie. SHADOWVANILLA {Duh} won't rlly include Purelily cause I don't ship themXD SH {Selfharm} Insomnia, Mood swings, schizophrenia and Angry Pure Vanilla!

Behind all the layers of goodness, Pure Vanilla Cookie's Soul Jam yearns to be fused again with its evil other half. He and Shadow Milk Cookie begin sharing dreams, memories, and fragments of suppressed feelings-feelings that were never meant to come to light. Feelings that could mean the ruination of all cookie kind.

(Uhhh I don't even know at this point in time. I haven't gotten to the part where they actually met so I'm just going off the things I know from fanfics and stuff.) Pure Vanilla's in the Spire where Shadow Milk Cookie is supposed to be. He got separated with Gingerbrave, Strawberry Cookie, and Wizard Cookie while fighting so he's wandering the halls, looking for Shadow Milk Cookie. Little does he know, Shadow Milk Cookie is watching him from not too far away.