Evie is a well-known artist-just not in real life. Behind an anonymous account, she quietly sketches the one person she can't stop thinking about: Andy, the dazzling drummer of their university's band. With his soft voice, graceful confidence, and unapologetically femme style, Andy is adored by everyone... and widely assumed to be gay. Evie has accepted her one-sided feelings, finding comfort in loving him from afar, knowing he'd never see her that way. But then, Andy unexpectedly discovers her art and begins leaving cryptic, heartfelt messages. Evie is pulled into a connection she never imagined. As the lines between who they are and who they pretend to be blur, one question remains: What if love isn't what everyone says it should be-but whatever it may be?