Dolly and Valentino. Sweet and intense. Crazy and serious. Two opposites. Two hearts. Two lonely souls. Dolly Armstrong is a crazy 19 year old with no experience of friendships or relationships. Isolated her whole life, she's desperate for a friend, someone she can waffle her heart out to, someone she can dress up in matching duck onesies with, someone who can tame her little crackhead self. Valentino Dominguez, a 25 year old lawyer who has no time for anything or anyone. He didn't care for a relationship, he told himself he was content on his own, basking in the silence of his own presence. That's how he liked it, quiet and calm. Until a talkative girl without the ability to be quiet stumbled into his gym. Can these two opposites ever become one?

Brooke Lynn Routledge, John B's sister, and JJ have been inseparable since childhood. After Big John's disappearance, JJ became Brooke's rock. Though Brooke is the life of the party, JJ sees her struggles and is always there. Sharing a house with two guys is complicated, especially when one has held Brooke's heart for years. As Brooke grows older, JJ develops feelings but a promise to John B keeps him away. Will their connection break the "no Pogue on Pogue macking" rule?