We all know the secret about Kitty and Ryder that is shared in "lights out" but what if it didn't happen that way. What if Ryder's happened like it did in the show, but Kitty's happens differently. Instead of Kitty being molested, she is raped, but who ever did it was smart enough not to leave bruises. Ryder has been secretly going to group therapy ever sconce his happened, but one day Kitty's mom thinks she should go because Kitty becomes depressed. What happens when the group Kitty's mom sends her to, just so happens to be the same one Ryder has been attending for years?