Sophie Foster promised to never think much of her match lists. But when they eventually come around will she stay true to what makes her, her or will she go with what's familiar and safe?

(100% COMPLETE) A Keefe x Reader where you, the reader, are brought to the Lost Cities due to your knowledge from the Keeper of the Lost Cities books. Keefe, having (sadly) finally given up on Sophie, falls hard and fast for the new human girl, but you're determined not to let him know you feel the same (this proves difficult given his ability). Through many experiences you and Keefe form a great friendship, and spend much time pretending that it's only a joke that you both want more. Also for new readers I know this story is really long it's quite literally years in the making, but if you want a good Keefe x Reader you're gonna want to give this one a chance trust😭🙏 You just have to get past the chapters I wrote as a 14 year old😬 Happy reading!!