The Best (Not Trash) FanFics
17 stories
You're The Straw To My Berry (Phan) by ughitssophie
You're The Straw To My Berry (Phan)
ughitssophie
  • Reads 5,110,566
  • Votes 187,414
  • Parts 53
Part 1 of the infamous series. Feelings appear. Sparks fly. Love rises. Problems occur. Please note: This story is now very old (7 years old in 2020) and I'd like to think my writing has improved since then! There are a bunch of cringey parts and bad writing in here, but enjoy and thanks for reading! :)
A Slender Chance by tkdoegirl
A Slender Chance
tkdoegirl
  • Reads 280,697
  • Votes 8,366
  • Parts 23
When Sky Steele met Mr. tall, dark, and dangerous in the woods one day, she knew she was dead. So why was she still alive? "You interest me," he told her. But why? And Sky just can't figure out why she's just as interested in him too. [A Slender man Fanfic]
The Killer's Girl (Watty Awards 2013) by MaskyisOMG
The Killer's Girl (Watty Awards 2013)
MaskyisOMG
  • Reads 459,004
  • Votes 14,316
  • Parts 57
Iris Morerose is a girl living with her at home father, her little brother who has too big of an imagination to the point of where it worries Iris, and her working mother who works from seven to twelve every day. She has a hatred for her father, who is having an affair with a slutty woman, but other than that, has a very happy life. Jeffrey Philips, better known as Jeff the Killer, lives in an abandoned city that is hidden using Slender Man's powers. One day, BEN, Masky, Hoody, and Jeff are walking down the streets of Iris's home town when he sees her. He plans on killing her when his life is saved by the girl. What follows is him falling for her, and taking her to be his beautiful lover. She, being her sassy self, has quite a few things to say about this. Will she escape him and his friends and go back home, or will she become the killer's girl?
Black Magic // Percico by Opheliac_
Black Magic // Percico
Opheliac_
  • Reads 155,643
  • Votes 9,248
  • Parts 31
✓~ Nico Di Angelo wasn't much for humans. So pesky with their small minds and lack of flare. But Nico was big on bets. Though he has an annoying tendency to lose those, much to his friends enjoyment. Make a human fall in love with you. Seems easy enough. Wrong. Cover made by: @LordoftheRabbits
Killer Protector (Jeff the Killer story) by EternalLaughter
Killer Protector (Jeff the Killer story)
EternalLaughter
  • Reads 7,594,363
  • Votes 195,542
  • Parts 82
[1st installment of the KP Series] Elizabeth always knew she was a special sort. Her family and friends knew too. She's an introvert and feels like a weirdo wherever she goes, even in her own home. But what happens when she encounters a man known to the world as a notorious monster? Jeff the killer. She never thought he was real; only stories told at school to freak people out. And now that he's come into her life, she'll discover just why she's so special. Monsters, killers, wraiths, and supernatural entities--how special can one get? There will be love, and loss, and triumph, and hope, all for a greater purpose: The human realm needs a protector, and that's Elizabeth. --- [S E Q U E L : Cruel & Blue (Eyeless Jack story)] *****-1st Place in Jeff the Killer-***** Cover art by: Asur-Fallinplim on deviantArt Disclaimer: Most, if not all, CreepyPastas presented throughout this story do not belong to the author. All credit goes to the original creators of those characters, anonymous or not.
Misfit (Phan AU) by MelancholyMango
Misfit (Phan AU)
MelancholyMango
  • Reads 4,108,119
  • Votes 101,435
  • Parts 53
Dan is different. He's learned to accept that. Well, as best he can anyway, considering he's never really had much of a choice. It's been this way for as long as he can remember, the constant runaround process of trying to feel normal. His life is built around it, trying to trick both himself and everyone he interacts with into seeing him as your average person. The isolation as he desperately tries to keep others from finding out, the bitterness that wells up inside of him each and every time he's reminded that he'll never be like everyone else, the fear that nothing will ever change. He's fated to be this way forever; a misfit from society. Isolation can only go so far though, so when he's struggling to make ends meet and he's faced with the option of looking into a serious job or taking on a roommate, he opts for what seems like the easier option at the time. It doesn't seem so easy ten failed roommates into the process, or when he sits down at a table to meet with prospect number eleven and ends up with a coffee spilled all over his lap. Potential roommate number eleven, Phil, turns out to be an insufferable optimistic ball of sunshine that Dan wants nothing to do with. His options are running out though, as are the savings he's been using to pay his rent, so he finds himself begrudgingly agreeing to let the other man move in. Neither of them have any way of knowing just what they've gotten themselves into as they shake on the matter, but time will tell.
A Slender Child by tkdoegirl
A Slender Child
tkdoegirl
  • Reads 157,567
  • Votes 4,206
  • Parts 24
Sky had always wanted to be a mother, but she'd given that up when she accepted that she was going to spend the rest of her life with Slendy. After all, she was human and he was... Well, the Slender man. So when she found out her chance at motherhood might not be lost, why is she so scared? (Sequel to "A Slender Chance") [A Slender man Fanfic]
Cabinmates | Johnlock (teenlock) by saltingcircles
Cabinmates | Johnlock (teenlock)
saltingcircles
  • Reads 352,152
  • Votes 13,207
  • Parts 19
Going on a school trip into the mountains for a month sounds simple enough. But when John meets his cabin roommate, Sherlock Holmes, a leisurely vacation soon turns into a hectic summer. [Rated Mature for smut scenes, language, ideologically sensitive material, and alcohol consumption] =△▽△▽△= Cabinmates now has a sequel called Exmates! Be sure to check it out after reading this~
(DISCONTINUED) PewDieCry: The Carnival (Collab) by PrincePhantom
(DISCONTINUED) PewDieCry: The Carnival (Collab)
PrincePhantom
  • Reads 17,985
  • Votes 1,046
  • Parts 13
A collab with _The_Masked_Lady_! <3 In the year 2040, the government managed to create a vaccine that helped people become immune to any form of illnesses. It worked, but there were...Complications. Some couldn't handle the vaccine, deforming them into atrocious monsters. Those "people" began to attack the others. Soon, everything went downhill. Eventually, they were placed into categories- 6 different types of species were identified. Dead Mothers, Almost Humans, Leatherfaces, No Faces, Babydolls and Rakes. These "people" were eventually deemed infected. In response to this, the government created a city called Lilly. Giant barricades were built to separate these monsters and to prevent them from taking any more lives. Cry has always protected his family from harm. But eventually, the food storage was running low and the leaders decided to recruit people for scavenging. This could only mean one thing, they would have to go to "The Carnival". Oddly enough, this abandoned place held the most food. The only trouble is that it just happens to be the place where the monsters decided to make their home. Cry knew how dangerous this mission was but he would never have expected to meet a monster face to face, alone! Felix sees the world through a bloodied lens. He has no memories of his past, his only memory being the unbearable pain in his arm and eyes. He doesn't necessarily care though, as he has gained a new family from his change. He never understood why the other people stayed behind giant walls, they would even hurt him when he tried to confront them. Yes, they have tried to harm them, but that was only out of fear and the uncontrollable pain. They became desperate for help, so they began to collect supplies and bring them to "The Carnival." in hopes of finally receiving some help.