Seven months after leaving Sterling Point, Ramona is still struggling to find her place in New York. When she returns to Muskoka for Easter break, she hopes to avoid the girl who broke her heart. The problem is, some places never leave you. And neither do some people.

Three months after leaving Sterling Point for New York, Ramona returns to the island with her twin brother, Connor, hoping to reconnect with the people and the place she once called home. But coming back isn't as simple as she imagined.