After Indie/October's kidnapping; Kassandra and her younger twin sister, Karma, stayed behind to comfort the Host Club and tie up some unexplained loose ends surrounding the assault. Two months later, Kassandra finds herself falling for one of the members of the Host Club but is too stubborn to admit it to anyone, including her sister. To make matters worse, Kaoru still believes Indie is out there trying to find him and despite Kassandra's best efforts she can't convince him to let go of his past. With time running out will Kassandra be able to figure out the mystery behind the boy with the broken heart? Will she be able to admit her feelings or will she be cursed to leave Japan without so much as a happy ending to her name? To make things worse, Kassandra and Karma have their own secrets, but will it be too late for the Boy With the Shattered Heart to figure it out?

There's something mysterious about the new girl. Something in the way she smiles is off and almost broken. She doesn't make eye contact, and when she speaks, it's with a horrid American accent. The more truth the Host Club tries to discover about the new girl, the more lies they uncover. Is anything she says true? Or is it all just one, big, hopeless mess.

Alice and Riley are two very similar girls. They both like scheming and breaking down people who need to be, and because of this they form small club to help girls get on their feet after having a horrible heartbreak. They usually don't go after the boy, but in this case they have to because their new target is the Host Club.