I'm going to hell for this. I got the idea from @MissMaccaSunshine and her "If the Beatles Were..." book so credits for the idea go to her.

In which a girl can't go a day without an anxiety attack and a boy can't go a day without noticing

Marie and Rachel have been friends over the phone since last year and when they meet up in Central Park, they think they can make their dream of meeting their Styx idols come true. While Marie loves Dennis, Rachel goes for John and the two friends get Styx tickets and backstage VIP passes to meet the band. Little did they know that meeting their crushes would lead to a huge disaster.