A man named Jerald Finsterwald gets a letter in the mail says that he has won a free trip to Los Angeles to compete in a game show called,"Which Witch is Which?" It explains that you have 30 seconds to compare 3 different witches to 3 different themes. If you run out of time or get one wrong, you are removed from the game. Yet, no one knows it is deadly to lose. Soon after playing, Jerald is suspected of murder as his fellow contestants are found dead, one by one.