Lily Graham was a rising star in women's figure skating. She had every chance of competing in major competitions and even the Olympics. So why was her brother Garrett disturbing her peace by flirting with her best friend Hannah? And why on earth were his teammates so attractive? Because even though her heart was made of ice, it melt for John Logan.

Everyone at Briar University knows John Logan. Hockey star. Serial flirt. Walking bad decision. And Riley Thompson has spent months pretending she's immune to him. Which would be easier if he didn't always sit too close to her at the hockey house. If his hand didn't linger on her waist. If every moment between them didn't feel like the beginning of something dangerous. They have one unspoken rule: don't cross the line. No matter how badly they want to. But when Riley starts anonymously messaging someone through a late-night campus app, she accidentally finds the one version of Logan nobody else gets to see. Honest. Lonely. Real. Now she's falling for the boy behind the screen while trying not to fall for the one standing right in front of her. The problem? They're the same person. And the first voice note changes everything.