"No, this isn't possible, I like boys." I thought to myself. I've had a boyfriend since I was twelve.. But why was she so tempting? I watched her hands as they traced my bare skin with her finger tips, the way her soft lips parted into a sly smile, "tell me you want me." She whispered in my ear, her warm breath tickli...
You don't remember ever meeting the Creepypasta guys. They were just characters in a story weren't they? Wrong. *Note: This is part 2, so you should probably read part 1*
Ft. Slenderman, Eyeless Jack, Jeff the Killer, Laughing Jack, & BEN Drowned. (Reader x Male Creepypasta). Msg me if you want any other creepypastas in this boyfriend scenarios!!!!!
