With the glee club and Arica's friends gone, it seemed that Sue Sylvester had finally won, but the war wasn't over yet. When Rachel and Kurt bring back the glee club, Arica is timid at first, but ultimately decides to rejoin. With her are Jane; a former warbler, Roderick; a loner, Spencer; a gay footballer, Kitty; a former member of the glee club, Myron; the superintendent's nephew, Alistair; a hipster, and the McCarthy twins; Madison and Mason. Over time, Mason and Arica develop feelings for each other, but Arica's past keeps getting in the way of her happiness. Will she end up with Mason or will her past determine her future?

Arica Dayton was the new girl at McKinley High, a mute. She had a rough past and wanted to make her future better. She had lost all hope, until she joined The New Directions, and she has Finn to thank for it. As she starts to get use to McKinley, Rory comes along and turns her world upside down, but what will happen when she has to say goodbye to all of them?