Select All
  • Time Is My Enemy(Sally Love Story)
    7.3K 363 6

    Sally is an 8 year old killer. She never had any experience with love whatsoever because of being 8...and a killer. She meets Jeremy in a park and 'plays hide and seek' with him. When she finds him, she can't bring herself to kill him. Something seems familiar about him, she just can't put her finger on it. Jeremy nev...

  • Heart Burn (Jeff The Killer Love Story)
    3.4K 123 3

    Years ago Celia's witnessed a horrific event of a boy who almost burned to death about the time when she was 12. She saw on the news they were looking for a killer on the loose, but she never thought there was any connection. 8 years later she stumbles upon the same guy. He looked even worse than from when she saw him...

  • Meet Me At Dusk (Masky Love Story)
    4.4K 169 3

    Izzy's parents and sister are killers. She's also a pretty experienced killer herself. Well, at least that's what she thought, but when she meets Masky, she's not so sure. He was so swift and effortless and he could take her down in mere seconds. She asks for help and techniques, surprisingly he says yes. They meet ev...

  • Innocent (Jeff The Killer Love Story)
    36.2K 1.4K 7

    Sienna is probably the biggest fangirl ever of creepypasta. Her favorite is Jeff the Killer and would do anything to meet him. She always knew deep down he wasn't real, but one day she discovers he is real and is staring him dead in his twisted face. Her reaction intrigues Jeff. He knew he had fan girls but he never m...

  • Book of Reality (an Eyeless Jack Romance)
    1.6K 75 2

    Molly, a fan of Creepypasta decided that she wanted to write an Eyeless Jack fan-fiction. She started writing about a girl who writes fan-fictions just like she did. Eventually she realized that everything she wrote in the book happened to her, even falling for a killer. Her goal was to find out how something this i...

  • You Shouldn't Have Fallen For Me (BEN Drowned love story)
    206K 8.6K 35

    When Talia was little, she had a neighborhood friend that did everything with her. After he went missing, Talia was more of a reserved person who didn't have many friends, but when after about 12 years later, she reunites with her best friend and learns the truth about what happened to him all those years ago.

  • The Lion Falls for the Lamb(Jeff The Killer Fanfic)
    167K 6.4K 24

    Teagan is about to turn 18, and her parents have to leave their home in Texas to go California for 3 weeks when her uncle dies suddenly. Teagan is more than thrilled, as any teenager would be to be left alone so long. But with the weather being so bad, and her unknowingly being followed by someone, could this month re...

  • Indesicive [ Eyeless Jack Love Story ]
    212K 8.3K 39

    I'm a heartless cold killer, I cannot love. I have to kill you, But why can't I? Lila is a 17 year old girl. She has moved from Alabama to California, The house she moved to is filled with surprise and secrets. Later does she find, She has always known Jack. What happens when Jack and Lila find their true connections?

  • I Can't Feel Love (Ticci Toby love story)
    65.9K 2.3K 12

    Kaley doesn't like to be scared at all. She can't even watch scury movies without being scured. Toby has been watching her for a while and he knows this. He decides that instead of just simply killing her, he's going to play a little game with her.