What if the events of Tough Love ended differently, and Tara Maclay still had her mind? What if Glory looked Tara in the eye and saw something? What if Glory saw Tara as a weapon against the Scoobies? What if Willow Rosenberg isn't the only girl Tara Maclay keeps in her heart?

What if Tara lived? What if there was a part of her past that nobody knew about? Secrets unfold as tragedy hits the Scooby gang and Tara is forced to tell the truth, death has been the monster under her bed since she was 8.