We know how rainbows are made in Equestria.... How Applejack grows her apples.... What makes Pinkie Pie's (or shall I say Pinkamena's?) cupcakes so good.... But how does Derpy make her muffins? The genre of this is horror FOR A REASON. Read at your own discretion.

Original story made by Ebon Mane. +A fan-made (sequel) chapter by me. ~ENJOY~

What makes Pinkimena Diane Pie's cupcakes so damn good!? Why, her special ingredient of course!