Select All
  • MLP Creepypasta songs
    693 12 3

  • MLP CreepyPasta Stories
    26.7K 609 5

  • The Shed (A MLP Creepypasta)
    20.5K 609 4

    Fluttershy, the shy, kind pony we have all come to know. Well, what if that's just what she wants you to think, what if the shy pony that we gave come to know has some....dark secrets, one of them being she's a masked murderer under her caring personality. I don't own any mlp characters or themes, this story is NOT me...

    Completed