"Please," I whispered. "Don't make me choose." He sighed, turning his body to walk away. "Don't make me choose, because in every situation, and every lifetime without a doubt, I will choose you, Arthur Morgan." Arthur Morgan x female!original character Set during the game - contains HEAVY spoilers for rdr2

Mary and Eliza wasn't the only women in Arthur Morgan's life, no. Before them there was another. A wealthy ranchers daughter that Arthur met when he was only 20 years old. This girl challenged everything about him, and he loved her deeply and truly. But the demand and danger of his life drove him away, what a strange twist of fate when the two meet some years later while Arthur and the boys rob a train that she's on. Will the old flame reignite? Or will the fear of being abandon again keep her away?

After an incident involving a horse theft, and a stranger running out in front of you on your way home, you're left injured. Arther Morgan, as he later says his name is, helps you out on your small farm to do the trying tasks that you can't do anymore. In trying times, when all is said and done, you can't help but ask yourself "What if's" like if you hadn't met Arthur all those months ago DISCLAIMER I do not own any of the characters in this story, but the storyline and plot is mine.

The year is 1899. Being a young woman from St. Denis and suddenly moving to a small town by the name of Rhodes, you tend to think your life and all of your work is quite insignificant; Does it even matter? You spend your days wasting away in your parent's shop that they own, working and making money, as much as you can as a woman in these times at least... You crave something more, something deeper & more exciting. And who knows, maybe with Mr. Arthur Morgan, you'll achieve that...? *Loosely follows the events of the game*

A hardened outlaw tied to a gang that's as much family as it is trouble, and a drifter searching for something she can't name, find their paths crossing by chance. As Arthur shoulders the weight of the gang's choices and the drifter continues to wonder, trust becomes a gamble earned through grit, gunfire, and mistakes neither can outrun. In the end, they'll have to decide what kind of people they want to be. For now? It's just bad decisions, sharp words, and worse company.

You rode up in the mountains after the rest of your gang- the O'Driscolls- planning to rob a train belonging to a Mr. Cornwall. Come to find out, the O'Driscolls weren't the only ones who were preying on this train.

❝Reckon I'm a bit like a dog, aren't I? She showed me kindness once and now I keep thinking about coming back.❞ ❝A dog is far too domesticated for you, Arthur Morgan. You're a wolf.❞ [Bounty hunter AU] In which Arthur Morgan, the man you're supposed to capture, not only accidentally saves your life, but makes it a whole lot more complicated. Status: Completed Warning! Contains foul language and mature themes. Highest ranking: #1 in rdr2 Disclaimer! All characters appearing in this story are owned by Rockstar, with the exception of some original characters and the Reader. Cover edited by me.