The Lost One
MrNekonome
Cara was a freshman, Leslie was popular, and Mary was new to public schools. Cara is torn between the two, crushing on them. Leslie was straight and Mary was dating Jacob, a best friend of Cara's. What could she do? Which will happen: winning one of them or being alone once again, single and heartbroken?
A/N: This is based on a real story but some of it isn't real.