Jeff the killer x male! Reader Nostalgic creepypasta boyfriend scenarios! Mlm DISCLAIMER!!! This story was written by a 14yr old in 2016 and it absolutely shows! I am going to pick it back up and continue writing cringe in our lords year, 2026. However! i am not changing ANY of the early chapters! I think it'd be fun like a collab between the 14yr old me, who was a fandom rotten gaybie, and the 23yr old me, who's like a pretty stable married gay.