Select All
  • Jeff The Killer Falls In Love
    4.5K 63 23

    Jeff falls in love with Jane Everlasting (This will be her real name, instead of Jeff killing her family and turning her into a monster, she will be the daughter of Dracula and his wife Trinity Everlasting (My made up character)... This is my very first story I hope you guys enjoy

  • You Don't Scare Me. (( Jeff The Killer Romance ))
    315K 9.7K 28

    When Jeff breaks into Livia's home, there is only one thing she can think of. Oh my god, it's Jeff the freaking Killer, in her house! The daranged CreepyPasta addict just can't seem to drive herself away.

    Completed  
  • The Lion Falls for the Lamb(Jeff The Killer Fanfic)
    167K 6.4K 24

    Teagan is about to turn 18, and her parents have to leave their home in Texas to go California for 3 weeks when her uncle dies suddenly. Teagan is more than thrilled, as any teenager would be to be left alone so long. But with the weather being so bad, and her unknowingly being followed by someone, could this month re...

  • Obsession (A Jeff the Killer Fanfic)
    491K 8.4K 28

    He possesses her, she abhors him. An obsessive love story for the sick and twisted.

  • You Can't Escape...(Jeff the Killer x Reader)
    387K 12.9K 69

    (Y/N) is a little girl who loves to make everyone smile. She doesn't have a mother or father but, has a wonderful grandmother who watched after her for years. (y/N) was always smiling until, a certain smile appeared and took (y/n)'s smile away. Will she gain the strength to avenge her grandmother? Or will she hide beh...

  • Sing for me [ Jeff the Killer Story ]
    3.5K 256 21

    I do not own any of the creepypastas, only my character, Melody. This story will be on hold for a time being due to personal reasons, thank you all for reading along up until now, I really do appreciate you all for the support.

  • Charity Case (Creepypasta/Jeff the Killer Love Story)
    29.5K 1.1K 30

    Ronlyn, or Ronnie, Holtzer genuinely wanted to help people. Going out of her way for a random person in need wasn't exactly an oddity. However, when she meets Jeff the Killer while she's volunteering, she finds maybe there's such a thing as helping too much. Jeff has a huge problem, along with some other major ones, a...

    Completed  
  • "Do You Trust Me?" (Jeff the Killer)
    460K 16.5K 38

    Her father died. Her mother is dating someone else. Murder has broken out in her quiet town. Her life is turned upside down. Rose meets someone. A lone stranger who lives in a house of misfits, whereas; he himself, is a misfit. Her town isn't big enough for two...

    Completed  
  • My Beloved Killer (Jeff The Killer fanfiction)
    259K 7.8K 27

    Jasmine Price is a 17 year old girl, who lives in Denver, with her abusive parents. Jasmine only has two friends Cam and Rose. She goes through life everyday being bullied at school and at home. Jasmine meets Jeff the killer and wonders can she love a killer?

  • Smile for me (A Jeff the killer love story)
    231K 8.8K 33

    WARNING: THIS STORY NEEDS SOME SERIOUS EDITING, WHICH I HAVE JUST RECENTLY STARTED DOING. READ ON YOUR OWN RISK. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED! ---------------------------------------------------------------- Meet Blare. A girl who once had a perfect life. Parents, an elder sister, friends, everything that a normal person coul...

    Completed  
  • Jeff the Killer love story
    306K 8.4K 23

    Lyric just started her senior year of high school when she meets Jeff the Killer. He had fallen in love with her before she even knew he existed, but she hates him...or she thinks she does.( I don't own any of the pictures used, I found them on Google Images.)

  • Jeff the Killer (love story)
    119K 2.2K 19

    A girl named Jessica Waters lives in Florida and met the murderer called Jeff the Killer..... but he decides not to kill her.... has he fallen in love with her? or is he planning to kill her by surprise?

    Completed  
  • Go to sleep love (a jeff the killer romance)
    96.4K 2.3K 30

    Allie is A normal girl... Until she meets Jeff.

    Completed  
  • Innocent (Jeff The Killer Love Story)
    36.2K 1.4K 7

    Sienna is probably the biggest fangirl ever of creepypasta. Her favorite is Jeff the Killer and would do anything to meet him. She always knew deep down he wasn't real, but one day she discovers he is real and is staring him dead in his twisted face. Her reaction intrigues Jeff. He knew he had fan girls but he never m...

  • I saw everything: A Forbidden Romance (A Jeff the killer love story)
    56.1K 1.5K 15

    She saw everything. She was there when he was in the hospital. She saw how he went completely mad. She's seen him before...in her dreams. She felt something for Jeff and understood what he felt; the feeling inside. Will they manage to be together? And...how?

    Completed  
  • In His Eyes (a jeff the killer love story)
    73.6K 2K 13

    Taylor was just a normal girl who lived with a mom and a sister. she was the bad girl in school, the kind that always did stuff just for attention or for fun. Taylor read creepypasta stuff but didn't think they were real. Jeff was a mass killer who had no love in his life and only killed people. he lived in the creepy...

    Completed  
  • Real blood(Jeff the killer romance) *ON HOLD*
    61.7K 2.1K 38

    Magic was never that interesting,killers and demons would never think of getting it.At least that was what I thought,My name is Alice and since the day my parents got murdered by the hands of a killer.Strange powers started gathering around me and the same killer that killed them is the one that is gonna be the one wh...

  • I'm in love? (Jeff the killer love story)
    39.6K 1.1K 15

    A girl named Darla ends up living with Jeff and Smiles. Soon after Jeff discovers that Darla is Slendermans daughter and they move into the slender mansion. Everything is going swell until some mysterious being starts to mess everything up when Darla and Jeff start to become more then just friends. (if you. wanna know...

  • Blood Lust - A Jeff the Killer Love story
    125K 4K 25

    Laura is a normal girl living alone until one night, she almost gets murdered by famous creepypasta character, Jeff the killer. When he kidnaps her and takes her home with him, what will happen?

    Completed  
  • Vindictive [ Jeff the killer love story ]
    530K 13.7K 37

    I'm a killer. I can't love. Why can't I bring myself to end your life.. Jeff is a killer. But when he spares Liara from her death, everything gets blurred. Jeff thirsts for Liara's blood. Yet he can't bring himself to kill her. Someone that was made to kill couldn't possibly fall in love. What will happen when Je...

  • Killings the answer ~ Jeff the Killer love story
    161K 5.2K 49

    Isabel was a very mysterious girl who murdered her parents at 8. After, her grandparents toke her in she slowly became more and more insane. Losing her sanity by the age of 13 she was a truly, cold blooded murderer. At 18 she's become a full blown serial killer. But what happens when Isabel runs into Jeff and the rest...

    Completed   Mature