"Paper Hearts" follows the playfully innocent romance you encounter during your teen years. The type of love that will always be in your heart, young love. Acacia moves to a new city where everything is hustle and bustle, extremely contradicting to her old city where everything is peace and quiet. Before she moves though, she confesses her love to her best friend. Glad that the love is reciprocated, they decide to commit to a long distance relationship. One night, she meets the dirty minded boy next door and he starts to change her boring life in to something exciting. As the summer nights pass by, her feelings gradually develop more and more. Suddenly, she is caught in a dilemma; falling out of love for her childhood companion and falling in love with the cocky boy next door.