He stood for everything she was against and he wouldn't be caught dead befriending someone like her, but when the worst happens and they find themselves in a similar situation, only then will they realize they need each other to discover the anatomy of a broken heart and how to mend it. Santana and Caleb are from two different worlds but they have one thing in common: they're both in love, but not with each other. Caleb loves Farrah, and Santana is crazy about Jasper, and when they both get dumped, Caleb hatches a plan with Santana to get their beaus back: pretend to date in order to make the others jealous. It's a crazy plan, but it just might work. WARNING: THIS STORY CONTAINS STRONG LANGUAGE, VIOLENCE, AND DRUGS.