Annalie Tucker has always lived life on the edge. She and her best friend, Nate Christman, are notorious for breaking into any unattended building in their small town of St. Petersburg, Massachusetts. That all changes when Annalie meets Jack, a Mormon teen who ultimately forces her to change her ways. Annalie is intrigued by Jack, but what happens when she realizes she can't get close to him? Annalie has never been one to give up on something just because someone tells her she can't have it, and she has just been told she can't have Jack....

When Annie moves she hopes to have a new start and not have to worry about her past anymore, but that's not what happens exactly. Annie has tried all her life to be the perfect Mormon but some peers in school might think she's to perfect to fit in.