When the pastas are sent back to school, what is the worst thing that could happen? Besides trying to kill the whole school. Here's your answer. If one of them was to fall in love. Sam is a Creepypasta fangirl. Her favorite pasta is Jeff the Killer. Her friends Jeff, Ben, Tim, Brian, Jack, and Jackie are the only ones in her life that care about her. Sam's parents hate her, she's bullied by everyone at school. But one day this lonely girl became friends with them. Let's follow Sam and the others in a little story of how her life plays out after becoming friends with killers.