Sequel to Running Into You Jordyn is starting senior year with Paige's promise ring still on her finger. Paige may only be a few hours away at college, but the distance feels so much bigger. They promised to hold on. But between late nights in a cramped dorm, new friends testing boundaries, Jordyn's bad decisions with Callie and Christian, and family secrets rising to the surface, their relationship is under pressure they never imagined. Skype calls turn into silence. Quick visits end in fights. The distance isn't just miles, it's trust, honesty, and choices that could break them. First love doesn't disappear just because life gets hard. Sometimes it breaks. Sometimes it stays. And sometimes it leaves you to figure out who you are without them.

Kyla goes to King, which is the top basketball team in the conference. Courtney and Maya both attend Valley High, who haven't beaten King in ages. Maya is a new student. She becomes friends with Kyla when they room together at a basketball camp before school starts. Maya was able to witness firsthand the rival between the schools when her school teammate Amanda breaks Kyla wrist on a dirty play. This isn't the first incident between the two. At the camp Maya learns that her teammate Courtney is gay and has a crush on Kyla. Kyla and Courtney know each other, through a mutual friend named Ashley. Courtney confesses she has a crush on Kyla to Maya. Kyla has no idea and no clue Courtney is gay. As the school year goes on Kyla, Courtney, Maya and Ashley all get close. When love surfaces, one will have to make a decision if love is more important than a game. With every decision there is a consequence. When falling in love, sometimes the first person isn't always the right person. Friendships are tested as feelings are exposed.

Paige Gregory just wants a drama-free senior year. But her best friend Alexis has a younger sister, Jordyn, and Jordyn is supposed to be off-limits. That was easier back when Jordyn was the awkward kid with braces. Not anymore. After summer break, she shows up different, confident, gorgeous, and dating the school's star quarterback. Paige doesn't plan on noticing. She doesn't plan on caring. And she definitely doesn't plan on falling for the one girl who could ruin everything. Because getting closer to Jordyn means risking her friendship, her heart, and the fragile balance holding her life together. First loves are messy. Sister's-best-friend crushes are dangerous. But sometimes, running into the wrong person feels exactly right.