The story continues from Let Me Love You Again. Ellie and Samantha finally meet while Samantha is back in Los Angeles for Christmas vacation. They try to avoid anything that could lead them back into where they left off, but it's harder than it seems. Will they finally have the future they've always dreamed of? Or will they realize their lives are just too different.

Ellie is mostly known as the lesbian player, dropping girls left and right after getting what she wants. Rarely ever getting too attached to anyone she messes around with. She soon discovers that Samantha, the only girl she truly had feelings for, has returned after moving almost two years ago. Can she change her ways? Or lose the only thing thats still important to her.