What if Elena had a twin sister Karin who acted similar to Katherine but is a vampire hunter? What happens when they meet the Salvatore brothers for the first time and fall in love without knowing about Katherine and vampires? What if Damon only wanted Karin because she's exactly like Katherin? Will they fall in love for real or just for fun? Her name is Karin Gilbert the other doppleganger.

(SEQUEL TO I'M NOT KATHERINE SO READ THAT FIRST!) Damon's humanity is back but only to disappears when Karin's death crushes his soul. Is Karin gone? Is it finally the end of the story... No. It's just the very beginning of the real Karin Gilbert when she comes back from the dead. How? Read to find how this bewitching Gilbert twin can now face the problems with the Originals and have captured the one and only Stefan Salvatore heart.

"How many Petrova doppelgangers are there?" Damon Salvatore wondered as he came down the stairs, to see.....four girls, each with chocolate brown hair, honey-brown eyes, and a secret. The secrets that have been protected for so long are revealed the night Elena Gilbert, Katherine Pierce, Carlotta Petrova, and Andrea Flemming encounter each other for the first time, and the lives of those in Mystic Falls are forever changed. Enemies arise, dark secrets come to light, bonds are formed, memories are revisited, and an ancient curse threatens it all. Do they really want the truth? One just may come in the form of yet another secret.....