When the vampires of Mystic Falls travel to Neverland and meet the demonic Peter Pan (OUAT), what will they do? When seventeen year old pre-vamp Elena falls through a portal, Stefan and Damon not too far behind, she ends up in Neverland. She meets the evil Peter Pan. He immediately attracted to her. But Stefan and Damon won't let that happen. They all go through an adventure full of magic, vampires, werewolves, hybrids, witches, and more. The three boys will battle for Elena's affection. The question is: who will she choose?