Supernatural Texts
Yes I know the idea is overused, but bear with me.
Mature
Stanford non-hunting au. Sam never met Brady, therefore he never met Jess. He's a sophomore at Stanford and has a different girlfriend, Mara. She seems so sweet and shy, but she constantly abuses Sam. He takes it though, because if she didn't love him, then she wouldn't get mad when he screws up. One fateful day, Sam...
In a small town, a lonely mechanic falls for the preachers boy. In this story, "I'll wait" gains a new meaning.