"Where's Shelby?!?" "Whose Shelby?" "My girlfriend!" "Max... I'm your girlfriend. I've never heard you mention a Shelby in the 2 years I've known you!" "I know she's real, Taylor! I will FIND HER"

When an old friend of Aphmau's past returns, her friends begin to question Aphmau's excuses for coming home late from her night job. Eventually, curiosity gets the best of them and they push it too far, only to find a dark secret. Not even a healed mind, can fix a broken heart. ----------------------------- I do not own Aphmau's characters or her Mystreet/FNAF roleplays. I do own my OC Jay.

They always told their viewers that they would never be in a relationship. Btw this story is told from Max's POV It will occasionally switch but Max is the main POV.