Jessica Barker's life basically consists of her family, her best friend Cody, her baby sister Marie, and her baby sister Marie's death. Marie died in a fire that burned down her house at the age of ten. Months have past from this tragic accident, and Jessie is still trying to cope with the thought of her baby sister no longer being around. But with death, comes life; and Jessie will stop at nothing to keep Marie's one and only dream alive. And to do that, there must be paper hearts.

Aria has always laid low in school with her tight-knit group of friends. When she meets Nash at a party, he's rude, he's blunt, and he's got more baggage than he can carry. Aria immediately dislikes him. But the line between hate and love is very thin, and a continuous game of Never Have I Ever may change everything.