Anthony's a shy boy who works as a cashier in downtown California and makes videos in his free time. One day he sees a boy that he thinks is perfect. Amazing smile, he was caught off-guard by him. Little did he know that boy was a popular YouTuber who had a channel called Reaction Time! He gets invited to his party and later finds out that his life may not be as perfect as it seems.

The prequel to the story All Good Things. We know Zoe and Anthony are best friends, but we'll tell you how they met, how Anthony rose to fame, and how, despite his endless denials, he fell in love with Tal Fishman. It was when they were 16. Zoe and Anthony were best friends since birth, and despite his sudden rise to fame, they always made time for each other. But everything changes when Anthony meets Tal, another youtuber whom he falls in love with. If only it were that easy...