meepmeepe
Sam was always quiet. He barely spoke, he didn't socialize, and he spent almost all his time in the school's darkroom, developing his photographs.
Dean didn't care. He didn't care about anyone except his little brother. Anything else was dust in the wind. His mission in life was to protect Sammy long enough to get him to college.
Gabriel created trouble. Sometimes for attention, sometimes for fun. He was popular, in that way where everyone wanted to use his reputation for themselves and didn't need anything else out of him.
Castiel had a condition. Not a disability, but simply a genetic slip-up that caused his senses to get mixed up and heightened. He never made much sense and was generally an outcast in school.
Its the end of the AIDS epidemic, and while gay rights are being fought for more and more, Stockton, California is a small town and you know how these things would turn out in a small town...