Jeff has always felt the weight of being alone. Even with the other Creepypasta, he was the freak; the outcast. They believed he was demented and insane, and maybe he was. Did it matter? Did that insanity, something they all shared, make him undeserving of emotion? He felt. He wasn't cold and emotionless like people believed. He was a person and while he might be demented that didn't mean he couldn't feel. He could laugh, he could cry, he could feel fear. He could feel love. But never in front of others. Never. Despite the hand reaching for him through his darkness, he felt Forever Alone. Could that change? Could someone like him find someone to love?

The battle with Zalgo has left a few scar on the Creepypasta. Memories have shattered and personalities altered. With Jeff so far back from the edge, Slenderman much make a choice. To try and get Jeff back, or leave him to a normal life. But nightmares don't stay dead for long, and perhaps a deal with the devil may be the only way to keep everyone happy. And alive.