Select All
  • CreepyPasta Soulmates (Undertale Crossover)
    35.8K 2K 15

    Soulmates. We all know them. Marked by a tattoo on one's body, to help encounter the person, or people, we're destined to be with. So why in the absolute heck does Sans have nine, and why are they all serial killers?

    Completed   Mature
  • Touch; Ticci Toby X Reader
    2.8M 92.4K 49

    [Completed] Y/N is a 17-year-old girl who has been isolated in a Mental Institution for 3 years now, every passing hour becoming a blur. Days are long, but nights are even longer. She's trapped in her small room, in her head. There is no escape. The closest she can ever get to the outside world is by looking out the s...

    Completed  
  • together || eyeless jack [✔][editing]
    75.2K 1.9K 26

    ㅡ Never have I ever in my entire life thought I'd fall for a serial killer. guys i wrote this like five years ago dont read it its ass

    Completed  
  • A Misplaced Note (TicciSans)
    7K 557 6

    Two worlds collided in the form of a relationship. It felt like Romeo and Juliet to those around them. Two people from different backgrounds and races met, and against all odds, fell in love. As a result, both of their worlds mash against one another in a battle that should have never happened. Maybe Sans shouldn't ha...

    Completed   Mature
  • Music Shifter
    671K 18.1K 60

    You are a secret killer for a few years, nobody can ever track you. You gain powers are from music Example: you hear the song unravel from Tokyo Ghoul, you became a ghoul what if the creepypasta's find out about you? This is a reader insert. YOU are the main character Creepypasta x reader THIS IS VERY OLD!

    Completed  
  • Forgotten (Toby x Reader)
    273K 11.7K 38

    Let her go. She's scared of me She wasn't ever suppose to meet me. Okay... If it makes her life better...I'll let her go. But...At the back of my head One small tiny voice whispered these words... "She needs you. You can't leave her alone" ----------- He was a monster He killed for fun. A sadistic murderer Yet every...

    Completed   Mature
  • Creepypasta Imagines
    181K 2.6K 32

    Imagines/Oneshots for all the creepypasta characters

    Completed  
  • I Got You ~Ticci Toby x Reader~
    287K 6.5K 26

    !Warning! May contain Inappropriate language, actions and killing !You have been warned!

    Completed  
  • Creepypasta Oneshots, Preferences, and Imagines
    89.8K 1.2K 21

    This story will include Imagines, Preferences, and Oneshots. Characters: Jeff The Killer Eyeless Jack Clockwork Ticci Toby Masky Hoodie Dr. Smiley BEN Drowned WARNING: Sexual content, Gore, Violence, Profanity, and sensitive subjects. Message me for requests! NOTE: !Please do not romanticize real serial killers! Anot...

  • Savior 》Ticci Toby x Reader {EDITING}
    544K 19.4K 23

    ~"The wind tugged at your hair as you sat on a bench and read your book. You had an uneasy feeling, like you were being watched, but you ignored it. You didn't know he was behind you."~ Living with your drunken mother had been a living hell. Everyday, you wished for nothing more than to leave. One night when you're ho...

    Completed  
  • CreepyPasta Parent Scenarios
    823K 16.1K 53

    Because psycho murderers would make great parents, don't ya think?! This isn't just for a female reader, but He/She. Here are the Creepypastas I've writen scenarios about: Jeff The Killer Eyeless Jack Ben Drowned Slenderman Ticci Toby Bloody Painter (New) The Puppeteer (New) Homicidal Liu (New) I own no CreepyPasta...

    Completed  
  • Before We Go; Tim Wright X Reader
    58.1K 2.5K 10

    [Discontinued] A young woman named Y/N is currently on the run from a tall supernatural being with only one goal in mind-get it off her trail at all costs. Although it has only been 5 months since this has all begun, it feels as if forever has gone by since she has felt at least a little bit normal. Her mornings are a...

  • Cry Baby - BEN Drowned x Reader
    341K 10K 26

    It started with tears, but will it end in tears? -BEN Drowned x Reader -Profanity -Mature themes -LGBTQ+ representation (cause fuck homophobes) -Don't be an asshole if you comment -If you don't like it, don't read it. Move along. STARTED: 09/22/19 ENDED: 11/05/19

    Completed  
  • A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING]
    142K 3.4K 55

    Cover By: mrsagustd93 Y/N L/N-Age 19 She had a friend from her past disappear. People say he's dead. Others say he's alive and killing. She wish both of these remarks aren't true and he's just at a vacation for a long time... Tobias Rodgers Aka. Ticci Toby- Age 19 One of the proxies of Slenderman. Doesn't really rem...

    Completed  
  • A Ticking Time Bomb (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    221K 5.8K 35

    A Ticci Toby x Reader Story. Feel free to leave comments/ suggestions and I hope you guys enjoy my story. *The picture I used for the cover was created by Adhiva-K-I on Deviantart*

    Completed  
  • Mine(Ticci Toby x reader)
    94.8K 2.3K 18

    Breaking up with someone who you known for a while can be hard. But with all this pressure of a love triangle is harder. Can you handle it all? Or will it go down to death?

    Completed  
  • Your ticks.
    74.6K 2K 8

    Ticci Toby x Reader Update 4/13/2023 Omg I wrote this book a longgggg time ago and then I lost my log in information back then. I can't believe so many people read this lmao. It has so many errors and it's so rushed I'm glad some of you enjoyed it though!

    Completed  
  • Cut it. (Ticci Toby x Reader!)
    217K 4.3K 26

    A normal dawn turns into a crucial kidnapping by the one and only, Tobias Rogers. Afterwards you raise a bunch of red flags that soon uncover your past. ------------------ Send me a message if you know the covers author. highest ranking in tags is; Ticcitobyxreader- #1 creepypastaxreader- #1 creepypas...

    Completed  
  • Secret // Ticci Toby x Reader
    255K 6.2K 25

    "In order to make sure that the creepypasta's do their best at their jobs, Slenderman has one rule. You can't fall in love or be in a relationship... But what happens when Toby Rogers falls for his victim..?" This is my first fanfic so feel free to drop tips to help me out with stories in the comments below! WARNING:...

    Completed  
  • Sober (Ticci Toby x reader)
    74.2K 2K 9

    •Ticci Toby- A wanted serial killer on the run. •(Y/n) (L/n) - A wanted girl running away from home. •What happens when the two cross paths and fall in love? Read to find out. - I do not own the character Ticci Toby

    Completed  
  • Sounds So Sweet - Ticci Toby X Reader
    185K 5.7K 38

    The goggles blinding your view sends fear tickling down your spine. The mouth guard mimics a smile worth a thousand words. This threat is here to kill you. Although you want to welcome it with open arms, the one in front of you still scares you. More neck turns, although now it sounds like it's the cracking of a neck...

    Completed  
  • A Dance With The Devil (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    81K 2.3K 17

    In this story we are taken into your life you are a sarcastic,fun loving girl with a bit of a swearing problem not that you care. You are about as normal as any 18 year old. You have school and other daily struggle any teenager comes across so you can imagine the horror you experiences when you come across a murder sc...

    Completed  
  • Hatchets (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    18.7K 816 33

    Ongoing⤅ With the recent death of her sister, (y/n) has to learn how to cope with the unfortunate event that has played out. But upon meeting a Strange man who wears orange goggles and a mouth guard, she soon finds a reason to keep fighting. For the sake of her little sisters dignity. ⤅ I'm currently focusing on my...

    Mature
  • Lie To Me~Ticci Toby X Reader
    106K 4K 30

    It all started with the Sickness: strange dreams, haunting woods and blood....lots of blood. Everything's inside your mind; at least that's what everyone kept saying, your illness was taking a toll on you and eventually, you were forced onto isolation from the rest of the world. Only for them to get you. They have kep...

    Mature
  • Perseverance
    244K 5.9K 26

    Masky × [Reader] (COMPLETE) _______________________ Things are everywhere and upside down for teenage [ ] [ ]. She's moved to a new town and has befriended strange people that seem oddly familiar. What becomes of her when she's fallen for her new friend? A/N: Y'all, I wrote this in 2013 during my cringe phas...

    Completed   Mature
  • Wolf & Pig (Eyeless Jack x Reader)
    524K 18.2K 30

    "That's right. I am the big bad wolf. You are the little piggy" He licked his lips "I can eat you up whenever I want..." ---------------------- I met him at McDonalds. He order a lot of food that he claimed was for his friends, but I didn't believe a word he said I fell hopelessly in love with him. Then he tried to k...

    Completed   Mature
  • Do You Remember? (Eyeless Jack x Reader Romance)
    271K 5.5K 23

    Jack goes out to hunt and just so happens to run into you while you're out taking a walk. After Jack hurts you considerably, he decides to help you live. For what reason? You have no idea. Now, you're stuck at the Creepypasta mansion until you recover. But what happens when you learn that there's more to the killer th...

  • Cruelest Of Hearts~Eyeless Jack X Reader
    389K 13K 49

    When the person you love most is violently taken away from you, you set out on a dangerous journey to find out what happened to him, making your life goal to discover the truth. What you don't expect though, is to uncover secrets that come out of the darkest abyss, accompanied by a cannibalistic creature with a navy-b...

    Completed   Mature
  • Trick And Kill~~Jeff The Killer X Reader X Eyeless Jack
    847K 25.9K 77

    How much can a human take before the reality around him snaps? For you it was the most unbearable loss of them all. It was more than enough to drown everything sane inside of you. The monster rose inside of you and everything went up to flames. But you are not alone. Madness knows no limits. The same goes for love.~~...

    Completed   Mature
  • Dark Eyes (Eyeless Jack Romance)
    152K 5.9K 36

    Sarah was always felt like an outcast constantly being looked down upon. She always thought that her ability to see thoughts was a curse, until Jack came. Jack came fully prepared to kill Sarah, but her abilities sparked his curiosity. meeting sarah will be Jack's greatest decision or his downfall.

    Completed