Hester of Ravenswood was one of the most villainous and fearsome witches in the School for Good and Evil, except when it comes to her best friend Anadil. Anadil of Bloodbrook may present herself as an emotionless, evil witch, but after the Trial by Tale in her second year, Anadil's world is turned upside-down. As the two witches fight to save the balance of The Woods, they also fight for each others' love. This book follows the love story of Hester of Anadil and 'Fill in the Blanks' in the SGE universe.

The next generation of School for Good and Evil kids are sent back in time to make sure their parents fall in love and have them.