Creepypasta Stories
17 stories
Just Like You (Ticci Toby x Reader) by SguiglySquid
Just Like You (Ticci Toby x Reader)
SguiglySquid
  • Reads 7,832
  • Votes 209
  • Parts 37
After a neighboring town burns down a boy about your age goes missing you meet a inocent looking boy your age. He doesn't seem like he can hurt a fly, but looks can be decieving
How Far Will You Go? (Yandere Ticci Toby X Reader) by ItsyBittySpider01
How Far Will You Go? (Yandere Ticci Toby X Reader)
ItsyBittySpider01
  • Reads 135,302
  • Votes 3,361
  • Parts 26
Hey everyone! Long story short I'm going to be posting the Ticci Toby story on this new Wattpad account. Sorry but Wattpad wasn't able to let me back in my original account :( ______ Toby seems to have new feelings towards a new girl. She's bold, confident, and surprisingly nice. No one has been this nice since his sister. To Toby, this is his dream girl. Only problem? She's working for the police force to take him down for a recent murder he did in the woods. It doesn't help that Toby is determined to make her his and his alone. Various thoughts and desires fill his head when he's around her. How far will Toby go?
I'm Going Crazy (BEN DROWNED x Reader) by JasmineWillow
I'm Going Crazy (BEN DROWNED x Reader)
JasmineWillow
  • Reads 49
  • Votes 1
  • Parts 1
Will you or him decide your fate today?
Normal // A Ticci Toby x Reader Story by justaperson2
Normal // A Ticci Toby x Reader Story
justaperson2
  • Reads 982,772
  • Votes 30,675
  • Parts 40
Ehhhhh I'll write a description later
The New Boy ( BEN drowned x Geek! reader) by beepbooprawr
The New Boy ( BEN drowned x Geek! reader)
beepbooprawr
  • Reads 76,835
  • Votes 2,794
  • Parts 13
you already know what it isss.
You're my new game. Ben drowned x reader. by Flying_Squirrel14
You're my new game. Ben drowned x reader.
Flying_Squirrel14
  • Reads 995,194
  • Votes 26,672
  • Parts 29
A story about a boy. And you. Read on to find out more!
Ticci Toby x Reader by TheRealFirstProxy
Ticci Toby x Reader
TheRealFirstProxy
  • Reads 84,415
  • Votes 1,247
  • Parts 19
[completed] You're (y/n), a not so regular girl with a not so regular life, you're only friend went missing, you were mute, you got abused, you were hated, you had no more hope left, no feelings to show but you were saved.
Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader by Apple_Chips
Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader
Apple_Chips
  • Reads 3,775,796
  • Votes 141,623
  • Parts 57
I didn't write this but I have been given permission to post this all credit goes to Valentinesdaygreen and a link below to the original story origin http://valentinesdaygreen.deviantart.com/
You're So Lovely ...(Eyeless Jack x Chubby! reader) by nasiapink
You're So Lovely ...(Eyeless Jack x Chubby! reader)
nasiapink
  • Reads 6,082
  • Votes 114
  • Parts 6
(Sorry for the bad grammar ...this is my first e.j insert reader.)
Eyeless Jack X Reader by ThePerfectBlur
Eyeless Jack X Reader
ThePerfectBlur
  • Reads 2,916,069
  • Votes 86,135
  • Parts 64
You manage to escape a facility where you had been experimented on. But will you be forever free? Will things go as smoothly as you hoped?