Select All
  • Frozen Hearts (Jeff The Killer x Cutter!Reader)
    15.2K 311 14

    "Just let me in and accept my love, please (Y/N). That's all I want..." He said, pulling me closer to his chest. I can feel tears at the top of my head, he's actually crying. "I-I'm sorry but I can't... my heart is frozen solid for a reason." I reply and gently push him away, turning towards the door. "I'm sorry..." Y...

  • A New Fascination || Masky x Reader
    235K 5.8K 30

    Y/n was never a very active kid. She usually spent time in her room watching horror movies, drawing, or playing social media games. But one day, her normal life took a turn for the worst, or maybe for the better? She never signed up to be pulled into a murders life. It was a simple mistake, but was it a mistake to fal...

    Mature
  • Forget Me Not
    357K 11.8K 84

    >Part of the Creepypasta childhood memories series< Thanks to Ben, Jeff is forced to walk down memory lane. He doesn't mind but you on the other hand still hold a grudge -------------------------------------------------- You and Jeff grew up together. In fact, you were actually Jeff's first love and first kiss. Then...

    Completed  
  • Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the Killer x reader]
    515K 16.9K 41

    [COMPLETED] "There's something I just have to do. Remember that incident with BEN?" I frowned and slowly nodded my head. "Well, I need to make sure something like that never happens. I need to make sure that everyone knows that you're mine." He smirked and took a knife that was on a night table next to the bed. "Ho...

    Completed   Mature
  • Personal Lock Down (Jeff The Killer X Reader)~Creepypasta
    330K 11.5K 65

    Sneak Peek: "You know I'm not actually crazy," His icy voice sent shivers throughout my body. "Right?" Signals of warning spread like a forest fire inside my head. Something inside told me to get back, get away from this man, it's only logical, but I felt like I would regret it if I moved away from him. He can't kill...

    Mature