Select All
  • Forgotten (Toby x Reader)
    273K 11.7K 38

    Let her go. She's scared of me She wasn't ever suppose to meet me. Okay... If it makes her life better...I'll let her go. But...At the back of my head One small tiny voice whispered these words... "She needs you. You can't leave her alone" ----------- He was a monster He killed for fun. A sadistic murderer Yet every...

    Completed   Mature
  • Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader
    3.7M 139K 57

    I didn't write this but I have been given permission to post this all credit goes to Valentinesdaygreen and a link below to the original story origin http://valentinesdaygreen.deviantart.com/

    Completed  
  • Creepypasta x Reader Lemons
    931K 1.6K 2

    Warnings: DNI if minor, Dead Dove: Do not eat, Threesomes, Rough, CNC, Not really lovey dovey, All characters are written 18+, BDSM themes. Tentacle usage, cringe names, Non-con, Knifeplay, etc. ||This is written for entertainment, Made for me to explore things that I decided to share. Always act with consent, let t...

    Mature
  • Virus (Ben Drowned x Reader)
    220K 9.3K 36

    "I love her more than I love my pepperoni pizza" ~Benjamin Ben Drowned A virus like criminal that could not be stopped He felt invincible Until the day he locked eyes with Y/N Y/N highly resembled Ben's childhood friend who had died Ben had greatly loved the girl. He was willing to risk his own life so that he could...

    Mature
  • Mad House (Jeff the Killer X reader)
    773K 24.8K 28

    Jeff the killer x reader Is it possible for you to fall in love with an insane killer?

    Completed   Mature
  • Nightmare or Daydream? (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    225K 5.9K 47

    (I started this when I was about 13 so please don't hate the first half too much!) "It was you all along, looking out for me?" Toby nodded looking down. "Of course." #623 Horror - August 30 2018 #255 Ticci Toby - February 1 2019 #12 Guy x girl - June 2 2019 #85 Creepypasta x reader June 2 2019 #295 Creepypasta - Janua...

    Completed  
  • Ticci Toby X Reader: She Is Diffrent...
    106K 2.8K 19

    ||RATED R FOR VIOLENCE AND LANGUAGE!||

    Completed   Mature
  • Tic Tock ( Ticci Toby x Reader)
    188K 5.2K 26

    What will happen when you meet Toby Rogers? You read that right! The Toby Rogers, better known as Ticci Toby, a very well known killer. Will you geek out? Will you get killed? Will you fall in love? Or will you hate him? Find out in this adventurous fanfiction! {I do NOT own any of the creepypastas, nor do I own...

    Completed  
  • Jeff the killer X Reader Bittersweet [Slow Updates]
    110K 3K 26

    (y/n) wasn't your typical girl. She had a small problem. She would lose control, the voices would win at time. It doesn't take long for her to leave her home and soon she is picked up by a new family. Now she is faced with a new challenge. Accept her fate and join them, accepting her insanity, or fighting it till the...

  • Scars Aren't Meant To Be Hidden (jeffxreader)
    214K 6.1K 13

    Slenderman found (Y/N) as a baby and raised her. She's younger than the CreepyPasta's being about 6 years younger than all of them (except slender of course). When her 15th birthday comes she gets a present she wasn't quite expecting.

    Completed  
  • All Stitched Up (Scars Aren't Meant To Be Hidden)
    30.8K 1K 6

    Book 2 of Scars Aren't Meant To Be Hidden!

    Completed  
  • The Boy In the Cell { Jeff the Killer x Reader }
    61.6K 2.6K 10

    You're just a simple girl (or boy xD) who has a mother that carries you along to her job. What's her job you ask? A nurse at a insane asylum. You end up meeting a boy, a certain boy. A boy that's interesting. Very interesting.

  • BOOK II: To Live with Ourselves
    25.9K 1.3K 2

    Jeff is back by popular demand, in a sequel for To Live without Fear! You and Jeff have settled into your life together, hopping from place to place, going wherever the wind takes you. You haven't had many run-ins with the law ever since you escaped from the mental hospital and Jane's wrath, but there are other, stran...

  • Music Is More Then The Name(creepypasta X Reader)
    42.4K 671 6

    Y/N was an average girl.In her eyes.Others saw her as a monster.Freak.Nerd.Why they did that to her?Why they put their lives in danger?No one knows.Because... Ha!Thought I'll tell ya?Dream on!Read or not.Meh no care.Meh write this story for fun because she ain't have a thing to do except doing her chores,breathing,and...

  • Wrapped Around My Finger ( A Creepypasta X Reader Fic)
    49.9K 889 6

    You were the idea of perfection. (Y/N) (L/N), the girl who can do everything. You didn't want perfect. You wanted different. You didn't want to be this "you" that everyone made you out to be. That your parents made you to be. That you thought you had to be. And then a mysterious suit man came. And you met serial kille...

  • Are You Suppose To Be Scary? (Creepypasta x Reader)
    102K 2.6K 9

    You were like a normal teen. You had a life, you had a past, and you just try to live your life. But your world is about to change when some killers enter your life, but aren't they suppose to be.... Scarier? **On hiatus until further notice