When Maka and Soul get invited to Kid's sleep-over, Black★Star and Patty forces Maka to take a risk and pick dare during their game. But everything goes crazy after Soul realizes he has feelings for Maka. And Maka realizes she has feelings for Soul too. (This was someone's story first but since they wouldn't update I decided to continue it myself. The first chapter is from the original owner @KawaiiOtaku01 but I made a few changes to the original.)

It was just a game they played on Soul and Maka, but it worked so well. MAKA X SOUL or SOKA I DO NOT OWN SOUL EATER OR THE ANIME AND THE REST OF THE CHARACTERS.

Maka Albarn wasn’t even that noticeable. Perhaps that’s why he came after her. Although, to be quite frank, he didn’t even threaten her. He lured her in like a trap. Perhaps this was why his jobs took forever. There would be monthly spans before the news shouted, “The Soul Eater Strikes Again!” or “New Victim has been eaten by Soul” or some other stupid thing like that. But Maka never believed that he was a terrible, no good, serial killer. She believed he went after the bad guys, as cute as that sounds. Soul “Eater” Evans the infamous killer who strikes at those when they least expect it. Except there’s a twist. He doesn’t just hunt for the hell of it. No, no. He hunts when he feels a darkness in someone. But that just wasn’t Maka. Soul didn’t have very much of a choice. The threats were always there. The guns were always pointed. Silence. Predict. Strike. As catchy as it was, his partner in crime “Black*Star” never followed the rules. Always yelling about God and shit. When a client wants Maka's soul to be ripped out of her body, can Soul do it?

Maka and her friends suffer from retrograde amnesia.