astroxbinnie
What if Emily and Aaron had been engaged back then before he was with Haley?
Emily and Aaron used to be engaged to each other until he met Haley in college and ended up falling for her. It caused Emily and Aaron to break up and call off their wedding. Emily moved away, and Aaron began dating Haley a little after he and Emily broke up.
Years later, Aaron and Haley were freshly divorced and he wasn't looking for a new relationship after his marriage broke up because of his job. He enjoys being a father to Jack and is still upset that he lost his ex-wife in the process of his job.
Aaron agrees to help out an old friend of his with a case in New York and ends up running into an old flame of his and causes some old history between the both of them. It makes Aaron think about everything that went downhill between them and wonder if this could be their second chance to fix everything that was broken between them before he met Haley.