❛ What if we ruin it all, when we love like fools? ❜ Joining the New Directions was supposed to be a fresh start for Alicia Hastings. Instead, it becomes a collision of music, secrets, and feelings she never planned to have. Caught in a years-long love triangle between Finn Hudson's steady warmth and Jesse St. James's dangerous pull, Alicia struggles as she grapples between comfort and chaos. With Kurt Hummel as her closest ally and a glee club that slowly becomes family, Alicia must face a past that refuses to stay buried -- including a familiar face connected to a secret she never saw coming. Along the way, she discovers unexpected bonds and a father figure in Will Schuester, years after her own father walked away. Here in the glee club, every song carries a truth, and Alicia's web of lies can only last for so long. ( seasons one to six ) ( © bakerstreets 2018-26 ) ♡ spanish translation by ; @valeispunk ♡ ♡ 2022 @gleekawards honorable mention ♡ ♡ 2023 @gleekawards best finn fanfiction ♡