Julie has been single for 19 out of the last 20 Christmases. Just when she's about to have her first boyfriend for Christmas, he breaks up with her. Now, she's known as a Mistletoad with a reputation for being absolutely awful. But when a snowstorm leaves her stranded outside a tree farm on Christmas eve, she meets the one person in all of Montana willing to give her a kiss. That is, if she lets him.