This story is about one fateful night, while filming their latest episode of Buzzfeed Unsolved, Ryan Bergara held his best friend, Shane Madej, close and confessed his deepest, most closely hidden secret. Mild profanity - otherwise, no holy water needed. First published: May 6th, 2017 Originally completed: May 18th, 2017

It was one of those nights, I couldn't take the fighting and like normal decided to sneak out to the woods and just walk. But this time, somebody followed me. A boy with a big smile and a white sweatshirt, who would soon become my closest friend and my closest enemy. He saved me and changed my life forever. His name was Jeff, but other people had another name for him. 'Jeff, the killer'.