Evelina Jones is a girl who only wanted one thing, to be somebody's first choice. But it never happened. People around her did love her, but there was always someone better. On the night before her prom something happened that distanced her from everybody she knew. After six years she comes back to New York and she faces all of her friends that she lost after high school. When she comes back, she catches the attention of Jack Anderson, a boy she had a crush on at the start of high school. Will she be his first choice? Or will he eventually find someone better? What will happen when a person from her past comes back into her life?