Before Toby killed his Father, His Mother got pregnant with you. Your mother would never tell you about Toby, only Lyra. But what happens when you find out about Your older brother?

"I love you in a creepy and inappropriate way." "Okaay..." "You wanna get married?"

(SLOW UPDATES SORRY I wrote this when I was 13 maybe I'll edit it sometime hehe) So this is my first X reader story I hope you will enjoy it, SO LET'S STARTED. (A/N: I don't own creepypasta or the characters, I own my OC and the plot)

Short after the birth of Eyeless Jacks daughter, Blue, EJ must become a parent unlike every other. *Completed* Book 2 is now up!

*100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite his insanity? What are the true stories of him and other creepypastas?