Taking place after my other story, "A Choice Between Two Worlds", it follows Cuphead and Mugman as the Devil swears revenge on them for previously beating him to a pulp. He plans to get rid of someone close to their hearts and mentally torture them before moving in for their utter destruction. Meanwhile, Cuphead must help his brother to control a powerful darkness. Can this darkness be tamed? Or will it lead to their demise? Rated PG-13 for language, violence, and blood.

For anyone who has played Cuphead, you know that there are two different endings: joining the Devil or fighting him. This story combines the two endings and stemmed from the simple question: "What would happen if one said yes and the other said no?" Find out what happens when this scenario becomes a reality. Rated PG-13 for violence, blood, and mild language.